November 3, 2026
Leadership Development ROI: What You Can and Can’t Prove
Most leadership firms can’t prove ROI, and shouldn’t promise it. What you can prove is behaviour change, and that is what gets a program renewed. Here’s how.
The short answer
Most leadership firms can’t prove a dollar ROI, because the business numbers sit in systems they can’t reach and too many other things move them. What you can prove is behaviour change: what people do differently 30, 60 and 90 days after the program, checked by them and their manager. That evidence is what buyers take upstairs, and what gets a contract renewed. So promise behaviour evidence, not ROI, and sell the follow-through that produces it.
Can you prove the ROI of leadership development?
Usually not in the way the buyer means it. A true ROI figure needs a clean link from the program to a business number, such as revenue, retention or cost. In a real organisation, that number moves for a dozen reasons at once, and a small firm rarely has access to the data.
Kirkpatrick’s four levels help here. Level 1 is reaction (did they like it), level 2 is learning (do they know it), level 3 is behaviour (do they use it on the job) and level 4 is results (did the business numbers move). ROI lives at level 4. Most of the proof you can honestly offer lives at level 3.
The industry hasn’t solved this either. Fosway’s 2025 research found barely 2% of L&D professionals say they’re advanced at measuring impact.
For a leadership or L&D firm, the ROI question shows up as three problems.
Problem 1: you only get paid for the event
Your fee covers the sessions. Behaviour change happens in the weeks after, when nobody is paying for anything. So the only part that could prove the program worked is the part that isn’t in the contract.
The fix (Sell it): offer the follow-through to clients who just finished, as ongoing support they pay for every month.
Problem 2: it isn’t used on the job, and nobody can prove it worked
In the LEADx 2024 benchmark, three in four leadership development leads estimated that less than half of training is applied on the job. Only 39% measured behaviour change and 22% measured business impact, while about 90% measured reaction. LEADx is a vendor survey of 145 companies, and LEADx sells reinforcement, so treat the numbers as a signal, not a census.
The fix (Prove it): check-ins, practice and manager prompts between sessions, plus a scorecard of what people actually do differently.
Problem 3: no one has time to follow through
In Training magazine’s 2025 Training Industry Report (US), 41% said a lack of resources or people was their biggest challenge. Even a buyer who wants proof rarely has someone free to collect it.
The fix (Grow it): follow-through that runs for them every month, so their team doesn’t have to.
What renewed my contracts in Japan
In Japan I ran intensive classes with McKinsey consultants. We would measure their score before and after, and in almost every instance their English interview score increased, even if only incrementally. The significant changes could only be seen over several months of hard effort, of course.
I saw firms cut the option to continue if the budget ran out. But in many of my engagements with teams at McKinsey and Sony, because we saw significant improvements in their scores, they continued to renew their contracts, and we continued to do intensives, especially with McKinsey consultants. I was even asked to continue working with Sony after I left Japan. Unfortunately the timing didn’t work.
That is the business case for measuring behaviour: results you can show are what get the contract renewed.
What can you prove instead of ROI?
Three things, all within reach of a small firm:
- Behaviour change. A short self-rating on the two or three target behaviours at the end of the program, repeated at 30, 60 and 90 days.
- A manager’s view. One manager rating per person at the same points. It is a second pair of eyes, not a performance review.
- Examples in their own words. A log of real situations where people used the model. Buyers quote these more than any chart.
Put it on one page next to one or two numbers the buyer already tracks, such as team engagement or retention in that team. Show them side by side, and don’t claim the program caused every change.
What shouldn’t you promise?
- A dollar ROI figure. If you can’t see the data, you can’t stand behind the number.
- Fast results. Real change in behaviour takes months of steady practice, not a week.
- Reaction scores as proof. Keep the smile sheet, but don’t call it evidence.
The 3-step fix for L&D firms and coaches
- Sell it. Offer the follow-through to clients who just finished a program with you, as ongoing support they pay for every month. They already trust you. Sell it before you build anything.
- Prove it. Run the check-ins, practice and manager prompts yourself, by hand, for one or two clients. Keep a scorecard of what people actually do differently.
- Grow it. Once it works, make it run for them every month, on your model, so their team doesn’t have to.
Frequently asked questions
What is leadership development ROI?
The return on what an organisation spends on leadership development, usually shown as a business result compared with the cost. In Kirkpatrick’s four levels it sits at level 4, results.
Why is leadership development ROI so hard to measure?
The business numbers move for many reasons at once, and the data usually sits in systems an outside firm can’t reach. Separating the program’s effect from everything else is hard to do honestly.
What should a leadership firm measure instead?
Behaviour change at 30, 60 and 90 days, rated by the participant and their manager, plus examples in their own words. Show it next to one or two numbers the buyer already tracks.
How long does it take to see results from leadership training?
Small changes can show up quickly, but significant change usually takes several months of steady practice. That is why follow-through after the program matters.
Does showing behaviour change help win renewals?
Yes. A buyer who can show what changed has a reason to keep paying. A program that can’t show anything is the first one cut when budgets tighten.
Matt Ainsworth ran corporate training in Japan, studied leadership and executive coaching, and has spent 10+ years mentoring startup founders on lean. He helps leadership firms and lean consultancies add the follow-through to what they already sell.
Take the Follow-Through Check · 2027 Edition
Describe one program and see what the follow-through on your model could look like, including the scorecard you could show a buyer.
Take the free Follow-Through Check
The Founding Five. Five firms. We build the follow-through on your program over summer (winter in the Northern Hemisphere), so you're selling it to your clients from February. How it works
Related
- Why leadership training fails after the program ends
- How to measure leadership training effectiveness
- Post-training follow-up: a 90-day checklist
- Learning transfer: why people don’t use what they’re trained on
- The 12-week Program to Product
About the author
Matt Ainsworth is the founder of The Lean CPTO. He has 20+ years across product, technology, sales, marketing and communications in Australia and nearly a decade in Japan, has mentored founders for 10+ years, and helps leadership, L&D and consulting firms turn a program or method into ongoing support clients pay for every month.