November 2, 2026
Why Lean Transformations Fail After the First Year
Most lean transformations don’t fail in year one. They fade in year two. Why the gains slip, and a 3-step sustain phase lean consultancies can sell clients.
The short answer
Most lean transformations don’t fail in the first year. They fade in the second, when the consultant has gone, the sponsor has moved on and the routines quietly stop. The tools are rarely the problem. What’s missing is someone keeping the reviews going until improvement is part of daily work. For a lean consultancy, that is a sustain phase you can sell to clients you’ve already helped.
Why do lean transformations fail after the first year?
Year one has a budget, a sponsor, a consultant and visible wins. Year two has none of those by default. The Lean Enterprise Institute’s Michael Ballé makes the point in Why is it so hard to sustain lean gains?: something like 5S is easy to start and hard to keep going.
The clearest data point is old but useful. Holweg, Staats and Upton tracked 204 lean projects at a European bank (Harvard Business Review, 2018). 79% showed gains. Of those, 73% still held after one year, but only 44% after two. So about a third of all projects held their gains after two years. It was a bank, not a factory, but the drop between year one and year two is the story most consultants will recognise.
The Kaizen Institute describes sustaining as taking 6 to 12 months to embed, which is longer than most engagements run.
For a lean or ops consultancy, that shows up as three problems.
Problem 1: you only get paid until handover
Most transformation work is priced as a project. The fee stops at handover, exactly when year two starts. Meanwhile SPI Research’s 2026 benchmark put professional services utilisation at about 66% in 2025, the lowest on record. Consultancies chase new work while clients who already trust them drift backwards.
The fix (Sell it): offer a sustain phase to clients you’ve already helped, priced as a light monthly fee.
Problem 2: the gains fade and leaders move on
A restructure lands, or the sponsor changes roles. Nobody is watching the measures, and the backsliding starts quietly.
The fix (Prove it): a monthly review with their coordinator, a quarterly gemba walk and a results sheet the sponsor actually reads.
Problem 3: it never becomes daily work
In Forrester’s research for SafetyCulture (2026, vendor-commissioned), only 39% of frontline supervisors said improvement is part of their daily work (source). If lean is seen as a program, it ends when the program does.
The fix (Grow it): coach their coordinator to run it, then step back once the measures hold.
From Six Sigma we quickly moved to Six Hats
Almost 20 years ago in my career, I did lots of work on process improvement and training. During that time I learned frameworks like Six Sigma and Six Hats. The company spent some initial money implementing frameworks for change and process improvement. But it seemed like a novelty. From Six Sigma we quickly moved to Six Hats, and then people just stopped talking about it.
The company was quick to make decisions half-heartedly, and quick to restructure. Even though we’d had champions in the business, it was forgotten. The priority moved to other things: staying on top of SLAs, covering the management roles made redundant, restructures. What I know now is how important it is to keep at it and stick with the framework. Otherwise you lose any gains you tried to embed.
That is how most lean transformations end: not with a decision to stop, but with the next priority.
What keeps a lean transformation going in year two?
- Book the sustain phase before handover. Price it, scope it and give it a start date while the main engagement is still running.
- Keep one framework. Don’t swap methods when the novelty wears off. Stick with the one the client has already started.
- Name a coordinator. One person inside the client owns the routines, with you coaching them.
- Leader standard work. Short daily or weekly checks by area leaders, not the consultant.
- One results sheet. A handful of measures the sponsor can read in five minutes.
- Agree a step-back point. Decide up front what “holding” looks like, so you both know when you can step back.
What should you do when a restructure or a new sponsor arrives?
- Brief the new sponsor in their first month, using the results sheet.
- Keep the monthly review in the calendar, even if the agenda gets shorter.
- Confirm the coordinator’s role in writing after any restructure.
- Take the new leader on a gemba walk so they see the area, not just the slides.
The 3-step fix for lean and ops consultancies
- Sell it. Offer a sustain phase to clients you’ve already helped, starting with the ones closest to the end of year one. Sell it before you build anything.
- Prove it. Run the monthly review with their coordinator, the quarterly gemba walk and the results sheet yourself, by hand, for one or two clients.
- Grow it. Coach their coordinator to run it, step back once the measures hold, and keep a light monthly fee for support.
They keep the gains. You keep the work.
Frequently asked questions
Why do lean transformations fail?
Rarely because the tools are wrong. Usually the routines stop after the consultant leaves, the sponsor’s attention moves on, and improvement never becomes part of daily work.
When do lean gains usually start to fade?
Often in the second year. In the Holweg, Staats and Upton study of 204 lean projects at a bank, 73% of projects with gains still held them after one year, but only 44% after two.
How do you sustain a lean transformation?
Keep one framework, name a coordinator inside the client, run a monthly review and a quarterly gemba walk, and keep the measures in front of the sponsor until they hold.
What happens to lean when there is a restructure?
The routines are usually the first thing dropped. Brief the new sponsor early, keep the monthly review in the calendar and confirm who owns the coordinator role.
Doesn’t a sustain phase create dependence on the consultant?
It will if it has no exit. Agree a step-back point tied to the measures, and coach the coordinator to own the reviews.
Matt Ainsworth ran corporate training in Japan, studied leadership and executive coaching, and has spent 10+ years mentoring startup founders on lean. He helps leadership firms and lean consultancies add the follow-through to what they already sell.
Score your best engagement
Score one past transformation on the free Engagement Pick Scorecard and see which client would make the best sustain phase.
Related
- Why continuous improvement fails after the handover
- How to sustain 5S
- Kaizen follow-up: the 90 days after the event
- For lean and ops consultancies
About the author
Matt Ainsworth is the founder of The Lean CPTO. He has 20+ years across product, technology, sales, marketing and communications in Australia and nearly a decade in Japan, has mentored founders for 10+ years, and helps leadership, L&D and consulting firms turn a program or method into ongoing support clients pay for every month.